Overview of oxygen delivery devices

This article describes different types of oxygen delivery devices including indications for use, how to setup and titrate devices, and how to choose between different devices. The focus of the article is non-invasive, low pressure devices. A full overview of non-invasive positive pressure ventilation (NIPPV) and mechanical ventilation can be found separately.

Here we divide oxygen delivery devices by the flow delivered to the patient:

• “Low flow delivery devices” – deliver flows <20 L/min to the patient
• “High flow delivery devices” – delivery flows >20 L/min to the patient

More illustrations of oxygen delivery devices can be found in our Creative Commons Image Library, and more information on oxygen delivery devices can be found in our O2 FAQ.

Here we discuss low flow oxygen delivery devices flows <20 L/min to the patient. Below is also an algorithm and job aid for oxygen escalation therapy in adults , pediatrics and neonates.

Nasal cannula (aka nasal prongs), is one of the most commonly encountered oxygen delivery devices worldwide and the preferred method for delivering oxygen to infants and children under 5 years of age with hypoxaemia, according to the WHO. A nasal cannula consists of plastic tubes that end in two short tapered prongs that are placed in the nostrils. When delivering standard flow rates with this delivery method (1-6 LPM), the flow of oxygen usually does not meet the patient’s full inspiratory demand, so ambient room air mixes with the delivered oxygen.If nasal cannula are not available, there are multiple alternative oxygen delivery devices to consider as discussed below - including nasal or nasopharyngeal catheters.

Nasal cannula should be sized by patient (neonate, infant, pediatric, adult) and can be secured with a piece of tape on the cheeks near the nose to avoid displacement, which is especially problematic in younger or altered patients. Gentle adhesive tapes designed for skin must be used to prevent skin breakdown, especially in neonates.

The FiO2 when using nasal cannula depends on the flow rate, prong diameter in relation to nostril diameter, the patient’s size and the patient’s work of breathing (which determine tidal volume and inspiratory flow rate).

• O2 Supply Compatibility: Transparent tubing with prongs included, suitable for low-pressure gas supply (345–380 kPa, 3.4–3.8 bar, 50–55 psi). Tubing compatibility with standard oxygen connection tubing such as a tapered or barbed ‘christmas tree’ adapter.
• Size & Fit: cannula come in ~4 or more sizes – neonate, infant, pediatric and adult (different prong spacing, diameter, length and flow capacity). The prongs of the cannula should be sized to not fill the nostrils completely in order to allow ambient room air in around the prongs.  Straight, curved and flare tip prongs are available. 3–5 mm internal diameter and 7–8 mm external diameter, anti kink tubing.
• Delivered O2 Concentration: 24-45% at 1-6LPM respectively in adults; Increasing the flow rate delivered through a nasal cannula increases the delivered oxygen concentration by 2-4% per liter per minute increase.
• O2 consumption: consumption is the liters per minute set by the user
• Single patient use.
• Indications: Patients who are hypoxemic, without significant increased work of breathing and require low to moderate FiO2 to achieve oxygenation goals.
• Special considerations: standard nasal cannula deliver flow equally through both nasal prongs. However, ‘sampling nasal cannula’ may be encountered, which are designed to deliver flow only through one of the two nasal prongs. The other nasal prong has a separate connector which is intended to be connected to a gas sampling devices (such as capnography device).

The simple facemask is a commonly encountered oxygen delivery device, not to be confused with the facemask with reservoir (also know as a non-rebreather mask). There are multiple delivery devices that may seem to function similarly to a simple facemask, but have unique considerations e.g. an oxygen tent, head box, or shovel facemask for ‘blow-by’ oxygen(NOTE: Head boxes, face­masks, incubators and tents all require high oxygen flows to avoid carbon dioxide accumulation (rebreathing), and thus can have significant associated cost and be considered wasteful. Also, head boxes and face­masks interfere with feeding, especially for neonates, infants and pediatrics. In light of these limitations, these methods are not recommended especially in settings where oxygen supplies are limited..

When delivering standard flow rates with this delivery method (5-10 LPM), the flow of oxygen usually does not meet the patient’s full inspiratory demand, so ambient room air mixes with the delivered oxygen.

Facemask should be sized by patient (neonate, infant, pediatric, adult) and are secured with an elastic strap above the ears and around the head to avoid displacement, which is especially problematic in younger or altered patients.

The FiO2 when using simple facemask depends on the flow rate, the patient’s size and the patient’s work of breathing (which determine tidal volume and inspiratory flow rate).

• O2 Supply Compatibility: Transparent tubing with facemask included, suitable for low-pressure gas supply (345–380 kPa, 3.4–3.8 bar, 50–55 psi). Tubing compatibility with standard oxygen connection tubing such as a tapered or barbed ‘Christmas tree’ adapter.
• Size & Fit: facemasks come in ~2 or more sizes – pediatric and adult. The larger the mask, the larger the ability for the mask to act as a small reservoir (100-200mL) to help increase FiO2
• Delivered O2 Concentration: 24-50% at 5-10LPM respectively in adults
• O2 consumption: consumption is the liters per minute set by the user
• Single patient use.
• Indications: Patients who are hypoxemic, without significant increased work of breathing and require low to moderate FiO2 to achieve oxygenation goals. May be a better option than nasal cannula in patients with nasal obstruction of epistaxis (i.e. nose bleeding)
• Special considerations: simple facemask should not be confused with non-rebreather facemasks or partial rebreather facemasks as described below. Flow must be at least 5 L/min to avoid rebreathing and carbon dioxide (CO2) accumulation.

Bubble CPAP devices may come in many difference configurations such as that show above, or a clinician improvised version show below.

Titration of bubble CPAP includes starting at a flow rate of 5 L/min, immersing the expiratory limb in the water chamber, to a depth in cm that equals the desired CPAP pressure (ie cmH2O); look for bubbles and titrate to 10 L/min if needed to generate bubbles.

The facemask with reservoir is a commonly encountered oxygen delivery device, and may come in one of two configurations:

1. A non-rebreather – which has a one-way valve between the reservoir bag and the facemask (to prevent exhaled breath from going into the reservoir), as well as two one-way (flutter) valves on the exhalation ports from the facemask (to prevent room air entrainment). Collectively these prevent rebreathing of exhaled breath and maximize the concentration of oxygen (FiO2) for the patient
2. A partial-rebreather – which has a one-way valve between the reservoir bag and the facemask, but no one-way valves on the exhalation ports from the facemask. Thus a patient can entrain room air via the exhalation ports

Facemask should be sized by patient and is secured with an elastic strap above the ears and around the head to avoid displacement, which is especially problematic in younger or altered patients. The tight seal required can be uncomfortable for some patients, as can an oversized mask which may irritate the eyes.

The FiO2 when using a facemask with reservoir depends on the flow rate, the patient’s size and the patient’s work of breathing (which determine tidal volume and inspiratory flow rate). Flow must always be high enough to keep the reservoir inflated!

• O2 Supply Compatibility: Transparent tubing with facemask included, suitable for low-pressure gas supply (345–380 kPa, 3.4–3.8 bar, 50–55 psi). Tubing compatibility with standard oxygen connection tubing such as a tapered or barbed ‘Christmas tree’ adapter.
• Size & Fit: facemasks come in ~2 or more sizes – pediatric and adult.
• Delivered O2 Concentration: 50–90% at 10-20LPM respectively in adults (Note: there is considerable variation in reported measured FiO2, though rarely is 100% feasible in critically ill patients with high minute ventilation)
• O2 consumption: consumption is the liters per minute set by the user
• Single patient use.
• Indications: Patients who are hypoxemic, without significant increased work of breathing and require signifiant FiO2 to achieve oxygenation goals.  Ease of setup and low cost may make this a go-to initial delivery device for critically-ill patients
• Special considerations: should not be confused with other types of facemasks described in this article

Air-entrainment (‘Venturi’) masks can consume vast quantities of oxygen. They are designed to be used when precise control of FiO2 is needed (e.g. patients with dependence on hypoxic ventilatory drive like some COPD patients). The table below shows flow set on the Venturi (Air entrainment mask)  – the total flow (O2 flow + air entrained) and the FIO2.  This helps demonstrate why at low FIO2 – the Venturi mask provides a far more consistent FIO2 than nasal cannula or simple facemask. However, it should be noted that relatively high flows of 100% O2 are required to achieve high FiO2.

There are multiple types of high flow nasal cannula (aka high flow nasal oxygen) devices.

1. With blender to mix compressed air + O2
2. With port/Venturi effect to entrain room air and mix with compressed O2
3. Without blender

Initial Settings:

• Infant <1year = 8LPM*
• Child 1-4 years = 10LPM*
• Child > 4 years = 20LPM*
• Adolescents/adults = 40LPM flow and 100% FiO2

Titration

There are multiple strategies for titrating settings that may vary depending on the setup available. Some device setups only allow titration of flow whereas other devices allow titration of flow and FiO2 (max flow depends on cannula size; up to 70 LPM for adults and 100% FiO2 ).

For pediatrics, consider:

• 0-10 kg        2L/kg/min flow
• 10-20 kg      1L/kg/min flow
• 20-40 kg     0.5-1L/kg/min flow (max 30)
• >40 kg        0.5-1L/kg/min flow (max 60)

In addition to being able to provide high concentrations of oxygen and some positive pressure, HFNC also helps with deadspace washout and thus may help with work of breathing. In theory, the consistency of FiO2 delivered allows clinicians to closely follow the trajectory of hypoxemia (i.e. a change in SpO2 with a constant FiO2 suggest a real clinical change). The good humidification of HFNC devices can also provide greater comfort for patients as compared to a non-rebreather facemask at 10-20LPM, but also can help promote mucociliary clearance of secretions.

• Boussignac is a low cost, easy to use facemask CPAP-like system that has no sensors, mechanical valves or electrical components. The system connects to an oxygen flowmeter/source that generates flow dependent pressure (8LPM ~3cmH20; 15LPM ~5cmH20; 23LPM ~10cmH20)
• Traditionally used by prehospital providers for cardiogenic pulmonary edema
• In patients with hypoxemic respiratory failure (non cardiogenic pulmonary edema), it is unclear if this device would work well in patients with high minute ventilation (Sehlin et al, Resp Care, June 2011).
• There are several noteworthy potential limitations:
  • Utilizes high oxygen flows
  • Limited ability to adjust FiO2
  • At high flows will cause airway dryness and discomfort.
  • No leak compensation
  • No monitoring of pressures

(See our Full Article on NIPPV/BIPAP/CPAP or our FAQ page on NIPPV/BIPAP/CPAP)

Non-invasive ventilation or Non-invasive positive airway pressure ventilation (NIPPV)

• Pros: May avoid intubation in some patients (COPD, cardiogenic pulmonary edema, upper airway obstruction) by decreasing work of breathing and adding PEEP
• Cons: Risk of infectious aerosol generation (possibly less if helmet NIPPV); risk of aspiration if patient not alert / unable to protect airway or if inspiratory pressures >20cm H2O; pt must be alert enough to remove mask if uncomfortable; skin breakdown with prolonged use; confusing terminology: IPAP (inspiratory pressure) = PS + PEEP; EPAP (expiratory pressure) = PEEP; PS of “5 over 5” is the same as PS ∆ 5 over 5, is the same as IPAP 10/EPAP 5
• O2 : requires high pressure/flow source to achieve high FiO2
• Initial Settings: PS ∆5-8/PEEP (EPAP) 5-10; titrate ∆P up to 15 to reduce inspiratory work; use higher initial IPAP with obese patients; higher pressures may require sedation in pediatric patients

Continuous Positive Airway Pressure  (CPAP)

• Pros: Delivered via face mask or multiple other potential interfaces to splint open the upper airway, increase lung volume & intrathoracic pressure
• Cons: Prolonged use is uncomfortable & causes skin breakdown; limited unloading of inspiratory muscles or provide complete respiratory support
• O2 : requires high flow/pressure source to achieve high FiO2
• Initial Settings (adults/peds): CPAP or PEEP 5-10; adults: titrate as needed up to 15; peds <12; higher pressures may require sedation in peds